Thursday, September 2, 2010

What are your thoughts on monogamy vs polygamy?

January 21, 2008 by Al Link  
Filed under Questions and Answers

 
"Being a big fan of Joseph Campbell’s, I found a post by you in the message forums of the JCF website, the one that was an excerpt from a book you’ve written, which talks about how movies should portray heroes that are warrior/lovers instead of warrior/destroyers and who are capable of forming healthy, committed relationships in which their sexuality is also expressed powerfully.

Either way, you already know what that says, but here’s the reason I’m emailing you, I’ve a question for you… From that post, it seemed to me that you were talking about monogamous relationships and finding a life-long partner to share an incredibly rewarding sexual life with.

I may be wrong about this, but just what are your thoughts on polygamy? Personally, I am more traditional and have always embraced a monogamous ideal. Recently, however, I was in a relationship that ended because my boyfriend kept talking about wanting an ‘open relationship’ and not being restrained from expressing love for other individuals. He felt that being with one single person for your whole life was both constraining and unnatural on human beings, particularly those with a great need to bring love into the world.

My first reaction was ‘Bullshit!, you just want to sleep with as many girls as you want and you’re feeding me this spiritual crap to brainwashing me into being ok with your inability to commit’

However, it’s been over 6 months since we broke up and I can’t help but wonder if there might be some truth to that. I keep questioning myself about the rationality behind monogamy. I love the idea of finding a soulmate you can spend your life with and grow old with, but is that driven by a selfish desire to have a partner’s full attention and devotion, or is it really the only way to build a strong fulfilling relationship??

I’m only 23 and have never been married or in a long term relationship… meaning something that lasts more than a year, so I don’t know. Is it natural to stay with one person forever? I want to believe it is, but meeting this guy has got me confused because he was very deep and very intelligent. He’s made me question my own values as far as relationships go. Perhaps because I was madly in love with him, perhaps because I’ve always been the kind to question things I have been told are right.

What are your thoughts on monogamy vs polygamy? I’d love to hear the opinion of someone like you."

 

ANSWER 

is having more than one spouse, i.e., being married to more than one spouse at the same time. Polyamory means having multiple sexual partners, and presumably all partners know about the others, and all are in agreement that such an arrangement is acceptable. In other words there is no infidelity involved, which implies secrecy and deception. We do not make any moral judgment about such arrangements, but there are serious issues raised by either practice.
 
Our personal preference is monogamy, one sexual partner only. allows for close friendships with others, but in monogamous relationships fidelity is part of the agreement, meaning sex is limited to just your partner.

Here are some issues to consider when deciding for yourself what type of relationship you desire.

1. Safe sex is much more difficult with multiple partners. When you have sexual intercourse with a partner, you are at risk from every other sexual partner they have ever had sex with. This is a big risk and should be taken seriously.

2. Typically the desire to have sex with many partners is driven by hormones, particularly testosterone (both men and women). In other words you are motivated by lust, not love. Of course there may be love, but there will almost always be lust as the primary motivation. Nothing wrong with lust per se, just beware of what is really going on. It is easy to deceive yourself and others about this, claiming lust is really love, when it is something quite different.

3. With multiple sexual partners, there is inevitably comparison between them. Most people have extremely fragile egos, anyway, and once sex gets into the picture the level of insecurity can rise dramatically, creating a state of extreme vulnerability. Few have the detachment necessary to deal with such vulnerability in a way that will work in the long term, though that is not impossible, just unlikely. Almost inevitably someone gets hurt—badly enough to tear their life apart. Maybe that person will not be you, but what about the others involved—you must decide if that matters to you or not.

4. Undoubtedly, the best sex is sex with emotional connection, trust and hopefully genuine love between the partners. There can be good physical sex without these things and if that is all you are looking for, no problem. If you want the deeper connection, it is extremely difficult to successfully create, nurture and sustain such love with even one person, let alone many.

5. We all have the same 24 hours in a day. Furthermore, we all have a limited physical energy during that 24 hours, though some have more energy than others. Time spent with one person must preclude time spent with all others (unless you are talking about group sex). Also, most men are ejaculation challenged, meaning that they ejaculate quickly, and after an ejaculation most men lose their erection and their libido drops to zero. Women are far superior to men in sexual stamina, so it is unlikely that most men would be able to keep up with more than one female lover. Of course, anything is possible, it is just relatively rare to find such a male. Even the strongest male can only service so many females during any period of hours, unless he has completely mastered the ejaculation response, and some males can do this.

6. The richness and fulfillment resulting from completely committing yourself to just one other human being is unimaginably wonderful. Using your monogamous relationship as a spiritual practice is one of the best options for spiritual paths, leading both partners ultimately as high as Enlightenment for Two. Learning to create love that lasts a lifetime is of the highest order of achievement, certainly ranking with supreme accomplishment academically, artistically or in sports. It is also difficult to do, witness the high rates of marriage breakups.

 In the end, we must each make our own choice on this, but certainly there is room for experimentation.

 

 

Al Link and Pala Copeland

4 Freedoms Relationship Tantra

 

 

 

Popularity: 2% [?]

Your Ad Here

Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!

You must be logged in to post a comment.